NURS-FPX4030 Assessment 3: PICO(T) Questions and an Evidence-Based Approach to CAUTI Prevention
Assignment brief and study model | Nursing | Capella University course alignment
Capella University’s BSN FlexPath course NURS-FPX4030, Making Evidence-Based Decisions, focuses on interpreting research and applying evidence-based practice to care-planning decisions. This original Assessment 3 model adapts the recurring PICO(T) assignment format to a focused clinical question about preventing catheter-associated urinary tract infections (CAUTIs) in adult acute-care patients. It is an independently written teaching brief, not an official Capella course-room document or a representation of a newly issued university assessment.
Assignment Information
| Institutional model | Capella University, BSN FlexPath |
|---|---|
| Course | NURS-FPX4030, Making Evidence-Based Decisions |
| Assessment | Assessment 3: PICO(T) Questions and an Evidence-Based Approach |
| Assessment type | Individual written assessment and evidence appraisal |
| Length | 3–5 pages of content, excluding the title page and reference list |
| Referencing | APA 7th edition |
| Sources | At least four scholarly or professional sources published within the previous five years; at least three must be peer-reviewed journal articles |
| Submission format | Word document or accessible PDF, as specified by the course site |
| Weighting and due date | Not specified in this model. Confirm both details in the current course room. |
Course alignment: The Capella catalog describes NURS-FPX4030 as a BSN FlexPath course in which learners interpret research and apply an evidence-based practice model to care planning. The public course description does not publish the live assessment weighting, deadline, or current scoring-guide percentages. The rubric below is therefore a proposed teaching rubric, not Capella’s official scoring guide.
Professional Context
Nurses make daily decisions about whether an indwelling urinary catheter remains clinically necessary. Unnecessary catheter exposure increases the opportunity for catheter-associated infection and other device-related harm. A practice improvement question must identify a patient group, a nurse-led action, an appropriate comparator, a measurable outcome, and a defined period. The PICO(T) framework provides a disciplined way to build that question and guide the search for evidence.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention identifies appropriate catheter use, safe insertion and maintenance, and prompt removal when a catheter is no longer needed as central prevention measures. The Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America and partner organisations also recommend organisation-wide programmes that review catheter necessity and reduce unnecessary device use. Students must assess how well these recommendations and research findings apply to the clinical setting selected for the paper.
Assessment Scenario
Assume that an adult medical-surgical ward has identified inconsistent documentation of ongoing urinary catheter necessity. Some patients retain indwelling catheters after the initial clinical reason has resolved. Nurses and the infection-prevention team are considering a standardised daily review process, supported by an approved nurse-driven removal protocol. The ward wants to determine whether this process could reduce CAUTI incidence without creating avoidable urinary retention, unnecessary recatheterisation, or delays in care.
Treat the scenario as hypothetical. Do not present invented local infection rates, patient details, or audit results as real data. Students with access to a practice setting may substitute authorised, de-identified local information. Students without access to a clinical setting should retain the hypothetical scenario or use a published case study approved by their instructor.
Assessment Purpose
Develop a focused PICO(T) question about a nursing practice issue, search for relevant evidence, and evaluate the findings from the sources most likely to inform a clinical decision. The paper must move from a clearly defined practice concern to a searchable question, then to a reasoned interpretation of the evidence. A list of article summaries is insufficient. Explain why the evidence is credible, where it is limited, and what it means for the proposed nursing action.
Learning Outcomes
Successful work will demonstrate the ability to:
- Define a specific nursing practice issue and explain its relevance to patient safety and care quality.
- Identify each element of a PICO(T) question and formulate a focused, answerable clinical question.
- Develop a transparent search strategy using appropriate nursing and medical databases.
- Select and interpret relevant scholarly and professional evidence, including the methods and findings of at least two key sources.
- Evaluate source quality, limitations, consistency, and applicability to the stated patient group and care setting.
- Explain how the evidence could inform a safe and feasible nursing practice decision.
- Communicate in a logical academic structure and apply APA 7 citation and referencing conventions.
Task Instructions
Write an individual 3–5-page paper that develops a PICO(T) question for the CAUTI prevention scenario and evaluates the evidence that could help answer it. Use the following sequence to organise the submission.
Define the Practice Issue
Introduce the clinical problem and identify the care setting and patient group. Explain why avoidable catheter exposure is a relevant nursing concern. Describe the practice gap that the proposed intervention is intended to address, such as inconsistent daily review or delayed removal after the original indication ends. Support the rationale with current scholarly or professional evidence. Distinguish between a general urinary tract infection and a catheter-associated urinary tract infection; they are related outcomes, but they are not interchangeable measures.
Construct the PICO(T) Framework
Identify each PICO(T) element. Define the population narrowly enough to support a meaningful evidence search. Describe the intervention in operational terms, including who conducts the review and what action follows when a catheter no longer meets approved criteria. State the comparator and the main outcome. Include a time period when it helps define the evaluation window.
| Element | Application to the scenario |
|---|---|
| P: Population | Adult inpatients in an acute-care hospital who have an indwelling urinary catheter. |
| I: Intervention | A documented daily nurse-led review of catheter indication, followed by removal under an institutionally approved nurse-driven protocol when criteria are no longer met. |
| C: Comparison | Usual care without a standardised daily nurse-led review and protocol-based removal process. |
| O: Outcome | Primary outcome: CAUTI incidence per 1,000 catheter-days. Secondary process outcome: catheter utilisation ratio. Relevant balancing measures may include urinary retention and catheter reinsertion. |
| T: Time | 12 weeks after implementation, provided the student explains why this period is appropriate for the setting and available case volume. |
Model PICO(T) question: In adult acute-care inpatients with an indwelling urinary catheter, does a documented daily nurse-led review of catheter necessity with protocol-authorised removal, compared with usual care without a standardised daily review, reduce CAUTI incidence per 1,000 catheter-days over 12 weeks?
Explain the Search Strategy
Search the university library and appropriate health databases. Suitable databases include CINAHL, PubMed/MEDLINE, the Cochrane Library, and Embase where available. Record the databases searched, date of search, main search terms, date limits, and the reason for selecting the final sources.
Use combinations of terms such as:
- “catheter-associated urinary tract infection” OR CAUTI
- nurse-driven protocol OR nurse-led removal OR daily catheter review
- indwelling urinary catheter OR catheter necessity
- acute care OR hospital inpatient OR medical-surgical ward
- infection prevention OR catheter utilisation OR catheter-days
Combine concepts with AND and synonyms with OR. Search for evidence published within the previous five years, then justify any essential older source that the instructor permits. Do not restrict the search to studies reporting a positive effect. Include neutral or conflicting findings when they meet the inclusion criteria.
Select and Evaluate Evidence
Identify at least four relevant scholarly or professional sources. At least three must be peer-reviewed journal publications. Select the two sources most relevant to the PICO(T) question for closer analysis. For each key source, address:
- Purpose and design: State the research aim and identify whether the source is a systematic review, randomised study, quasi-experimental project, cohort study, cross-sectional study, or professional practice guideline.
- Setting and participants: Describe the clinical context, population, sample, or evidence base. State whether it resembles the population in the PICO(T) question.
- Intervention and comparator: Explain what the researchers or guideline authors evaluated and what it was compared with.
- Findings: Report the results that directly relate to the clinical question. Use accurate outcome definitions and units.
- Quality and limitations: Consider study design, sample size, risk of bias, measurement, follow-up, consistency, and generalisability.
- Clinical relevance: Explain what the findings support, what they do not establish, and how they could inform a decision in the stated care setting.
Discuss the Practice Decision
State whether the evidence supports further consideration, a monitored pilot, or no change to the current process. Do not claim that the literature proves a particular intervention will produce the same effect in every hospital. Explain any local approvals, staff education, scope-of-practice requirements, infection-prevention input, and documentation standards that would be needed before implementation. Identify how the outcome would be monitored, including CAUTI per 1,000 catheter-days and at least one balancing measure.
Conclude the Paper
Restate the practice issue and PICO(T) question in concise terms. Summarise the strongest evidence and its main limitations. State the most defensible clinical implication. Avoid introducing new studies or claims in the conclusion.
Submission Requirements
- Submit an individual paper of 3–5 pages, excluding the title page and references.
- Use APA 7 student-paper formatting unless the current course room specifies otherwise. Include a title page, page numbers, double spacing, and a readable 12-point font.
- Use a minimum of four scholarly or professional sources published within the previous five years. At least three sources must be peer-reviewed journal articles.
- Use current clinical guidance and research. A professional guideline may supplement, but should not replace, evaluation of peer-reviewed evidence.
- Support clinical claims, statistics, and interpretations with in-text citations. Every cited source must appear in the reference list.
- Do not include patient names, dates of birth, record numbers, photographs, or other identifying details.
- Do not treat this academic exercise as authorisation to change clinical practice. Any real protocol requires local governance, clinical leadership, and patient-safety approval.
- Save the final assessment to an ePortfolio only where the current course-room instructions require it.
Proposed Marking Rubric
The following 100-point rubric is a model for instructors and learners. It translates the recurring assessment criteria into transparent performance standards. It is not Capella University’s official scoring guide or weighting.
| Criterion | Weight | High achievement | Developing performance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Practice issue and rationale | 15% | Defines a specific nursing practice gap, explains its patient-safety significance, and supports the rationale with relevant evidence. | Describes a broad concern but provides limited context, weak rationale, or unclear practice implications. |
| PICO(T) question | 20% | Defines the population, intervention, comparison, outcome, and relevant time period precisely; the question is answerable and internally consistent. | Omits or confuses elements, uses vague outcomes, or frames a question that cannot be answered with the proposed evidence. |
| Search strategy and source selection | 15% | Identifies suitable databases, search concepts, date limits, and selection logic; sources closely match the question and recency requirements. | Provides little search detail, relies on weak sources, or does not explain why the selected evidence is relevant. |
| Interpretation and appraisal of evidence | 25% | Accurately explains at least two key sources, evaluates their designs and findings, identifies limitations, and distinguishes association from causation. | Mostly summarises sources, misstates results, overlooks methodological weaknesses, or gives little critical appraisal. |
| Clinical relevance and decision | 15% | Connects the evidence to a feasible nursing decision, recognises local scope and governance requirements, and proposes meaningful outcome and balancing measures. | Offers a generic recommendation without a clear link to the evidence, feasibility, safety, or outcome measurement. |
| Academic communication and APA 7 | 10% | Organises the paper logically, writes clearly and professionally, and applies accurate in-text citations and references. | Contains organisational, language, citation, or reference errors that interfere with clarity or source traceability. |
Performance bands: Excellent: 85–100; Good: 70–84; Satisfactory: 50–69; Not yet satisfactory: below 50. These bands are illustrative and should be replaced with the institution’s approved grading scale where required.
Evidence-Based Nursing Paper Example
Nurse-Led Catheter Review
Adult medical-surgical patients with indwelling urinary catheters may remain exposed to avoidable infection risk when staff do not review the continuing indication consistently. Patel et al. (2023), in Strategies to prevent catheter-associated urinary tract infections in acute-care hospitals: 2022 Update, recommend organisation-wide programmes that identify and remove catheters that are no longer necessary, including regular review of catheter necessity. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Clinical Safety: Preventing Catheter-associated Urinary Tract Infections guidance also identifies prompt removal after the clinical indication ends as a core prevention measure. The practice question should therefore examine a defined nursing process rather than general infection education alone. The population is adult acute-care inpatients with an indwelling urinary catheter, and the intervention is a documented daily nurse-led review with removal under an approved protocol when criteria are no longer met. The primary outcome is CAUTI incidence per 1,000 catheter-days, while catheter utilisation and recatheterisation can be tracked as secondary or balancing measures. A 12-week evaluation period gives the question a defined time boundary, although the student should explain whether the local patient volume is sufficient to assess change over that period.
Interpreting Nursing Evidence
Su’s (2025) Effectiveness of Nurse-Driven Protocols in Reducing Catheter-Associated Urinary Tract Infections: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis examined ten studies involving 27,965 patients in nurse-driven protocol groups and 30,230 controls. The review reported lower catheter utilisation and lower CAUTI incidence in groups using nurse-driven protocols, which supports further consideration of structured nurse-led review. Pajerski et al. (2022), in A Clinical Nurse Specialist-Led Initiative to Reduce Catheter-Associated Urinary Tract Infection Rates Using a Best Practice Guideline, reported a fall in CAUTI rates from 16.67 to zero per 1,000 catheter-days after a programme combining education, competency work, simulation, and audits. The result is promising, but the before-and-after project cannot isolate the effect of daily review from the other intervention components. Karami et al. (2025) found an inverse association between nurses’ CAUTI-prevention knowledge and practice scores and infection incidence across five intensive care units, although its cross-sectional design does not establish causation. Chang et al. (2026), in a newly published systematic review and meta-analysis of nursing and nurse-led interventions, reported an association between nursing interventions and lower CAUTI incidence, but rated the certainty of the CAUTI evidence as low. Patel et al. (2023) provide a professional guideline basis for assessing whether the reviewed practices align with current acute-care recommendations. Taken together, the evidence supports considering a locally approved and monitored nurse-led review process, but it does not justify promising the same numerical reduction in every clinical setting.
Further Clinical Analysis
Are Nurse-Led Reviews Effective?
Evidence suggests that nurse-driven catheter protocols can reduce unnecessary catheter exposure and may lower CAUTI rates, but intervention design matters. Programmes often combine indication checks with staff education, competency assessment, documentation audits, and feedback. A student should identify which components the selected studies actually tested instead of attributing the full outcome to one activity. The 2025 systematic review by Su provides pooled evidence, while the 2022 clinical nurse specialist initiative by Pajerski et al. offers an applied example from a rehabilitation setting. Differences in clinical population and study design limit direct comparison between those sources. A careful conclusion therefore recommends a context-specific evaluation rather than assuming that a published effect will transfer unchanged to every acute-care ward.
Choosing Meaningful Outcomes
CAUTI incidence per 1,000 catheter-days is more specific to the stated clinical question than a general count of urinary tract infections. Catheter utilisation helps show whether the intervention changes exposure to the device, which is a relevant process measure. Recatheterisation and urinary retention should also be considered because a removal protocol must avoid creating a different patient-safety problem. The student should state the surveillance definition used by the selected evidence and avoid comparing outcomes that use different definitions without explanation. Patel et al. (2023) provide acute-care recommendations, while the CDC’s 2025 clinical safety page highlights appropriate use, safe insertion and maintenance, and timely removal. Clear outcome definitions make the PICO(T) question easier to search and the evidence easier to interpret.
Building a Searchable Evidence Trail
A credible search record allows a reader to understand how the student selected the final evidence. The search should combine the condition, patient group, intervention, and care setting, using both subject headings and free-text terms when the database supports them. Search terms should include neutral wording such as “catheter review” and “catheter removal,” not only terms that imply a successful reduction. Students should record the date of each search, the databases used, publication limits, and the reason for excluding sources that do not fit the question. A current guideline can establish accepted practice, while a systematic review or primary study can help evaluate effectiveness and implementation. The strongest discussion compares study quality and relevance instead of treating every source as equally persuasive.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does PICO(T) mean in a nursing assignment?
PICO(T) stands for Patient or Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome, and Time. The framework helps a nurse turn a broad clinical concern into a focused question that can guide an evidence search.
How long is the NURS-FPX4030 Assessment 3 model paper?
The model follows the recurring Capella-style requirement of 3–5 pages of content, excluding the title page and reference list. The current course-room instructions take precedence if the live assessment changes.
How many sources should the paper include?
The model requires at least four recent scholarly or professional sources, with at least three peer-reviewed journal articles. At least two of the most relevant sources must receive detailed analysis rather than brief summary.
Conclusion
A PICO(T) question gives the CAUTI prevention issue a clear population, intervention, comparator, outcome, and time period. The evidence reviewed supports structured assessment of catheter necessity and prompt removal when the clinical indication has ended. However, study designs and intervention components differ, so students must avoid treating every reported reduction as proof that the same protocol will work in every hospital. A defensible nursing decision should combine current guidelines with critical appraisal of relevant research and local clinical requirements. The final paper should explain both the potential benefit and the safeguards needed to avoid urinary retention or unnecessary recatheterisation. Clear outcome definitions and transparent source selection make the proposed practice decision more credible.
References
Use the following peer-reviewed sources as a starting point for the CAUTI topic. Retrieve each source through a university library or the publisher and confirm the details before submission.
- Chang, X., Zhang, W., Fan, X., & Wu, Y. (2026). Effectiveness of nursing and nursing-led interventions in reducing urinary tract infections and catheter-associated urinary tract infections: A systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Nursing. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12912-026-05643-3
- Karami, A., Majedi, M. A., Kamyari, N., & Vatandost, S. (2025). Correlation between nurses’ knowledge and practices in prevention of catheter-associated urinary tract infection (CAUTI) with UTI incidence in ICU. BMC Nursing, 24, Article 1252. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12912-025-03910-3
- Pajerski, D. M., Harlan, M. D., Ren, D., & Tuite, P. K. (2022). A clinical nurse specialist-led initiative to reduce catheter-associated urinary tract infection rates using a best practice guideline. Clinical Nurse Specialist, 36(1), 20–28. https://doi.org/10.1097/NUR.0000000000000643
- Patel, P. K., Advani, S. D., Kofman, A. D., Lo, E., Maragakis, L. L., Pegues, D. A., Pettis, A. M., Saint, S., Trautner, B., Yokoe, D. S., & Meddings, J. (2023). Strategies to prevent catheter-associated urinary tract infections in acute-care hospitals: 2022 update. Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology, 44(8), 1209–1231. https://doi.org/10.1017/ice.2023.137
- Su, L. (2025). Effectiveness of nurse-driven protocols in reducing catheter-associated urinary tract infections: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Nursing Care Quality, 40(1), 39–45. https://doi.org/10.1097/NCQ.0000000000000811
Professional Guidance
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2025, June 27). Clinical safety: Preventing catheter-associated urinary tract infections (CAUTIs). https://www.cdc.gov/uti/hcp/clinical-safety/
Nurse-Led Daily Catheter Review and CAUTI Prevention in Adult Acute Care: A PICO(T) Evidence Appraisal
The Practice Issue
Some patients on adult medical-surgical wards keep an indwelling urinary catheter long after the original reason for insertion has passed. A catheter placed during surgery may stay in because nobody recorded a stop date, or because the daily check never took place. Every extra day adds exposure to the device and to the infection risk that comes with it. Patel et al. (2023) recommend organisation-wide programmes that identify catheters no longer needed and remove them. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC, 2025) lists prompt removal after the indication ends among its core prevention measures. The gap on the ward in this scenario is therefore inconsistent documentation of ongoing necessity, not ignorance that catheters carry risk. Terminology also matters. A urinary tract infection is a general clinical diagnosis, whereas a catheter-associated urinary tract infection (CAUTI) is a surveillance event tied to a catheter, so the two terms cannot stand in for each other as outcome measures. The scenario is hypothetical, and the paper assumes no local infection rates.
The PICO(T) Question
The question needs a patient group, an action a nurse can own, a comparator, a measurable result and a time frame. Each element is set out below.
- Population: adult inpatients in an acute-care hospital with an indwelling urinary catheter.
- Intervention: a documented daily nurse-led review of catheter indication, followed by removal under an institutionally approved nurse-driven protocol when criteria are no longer met.
- Comparison: usual care without a standardised daily review or protocol-based removal.
- Outcome: CAUTI incidence per 1,000 catheter-days, with catheter utilisation ratio as a process measure.
- Time: 12 weeks after implementation.
The full question reads: in adult acute-care inpatients with an indwelling urinary catheter, does a documented daily nurse-led review of catheter necessity with protocol-authorised removal, compared with usual care without a standardised daily review, reduce CAUTI incidence per 1,000 catheter-days over 12 weeks? The wording names who performs the review and what happens next, which keeps the intervention concrete enough to search and to audit. The 12-week window carries a risk on a small ward. If the unit accumulates few catheter-days, a single infection can swing the rate sharply, and the data may show noise instead of change. The time frame is defensible only if local catheter-day volume is large enough to support the comparison, and the paper treats that as a condition, not an assumption.
Search Strategy
The search plan covers CINAHL, PubMed/MEDLINE and the Cochrane Library, with Embase added where the library provides it. Concept blocks join with AND and synonyms within each block join with OR. The first block pairs “catheter-associated urinary tract infection” with CAUTI. The second covers nurse-driven protocol, nurse-led removal and daily catheter review. The third captures indwelling urinary catheter and catheter necessity. The fourth names the setting, with terms such as acute care, hospital inpatient and medical-surgical ward. A final block adds catheter utilisation and catheter-days to anchor the outcomes. Neutral phrases such as “catheter review” and “catheter removal” sit beside outcome-friendly terms, because a search built only on words that imply success would skew the evidence toward positive findings. Date limits cover the previous five years, and any older source needs a stated reason and instructor approval. The search record should log the databases, the date of each search, the limits applied and the reason each excluded source failed the question.
Appraising the Evidence
Pooled Evidence on Nurse-Driven Protocols
Su (2025) pooled ten studies in a systematic review and meta-analysis, comparing 27,965 patients managed under nurse-driven protocols with 30,230 controls. The review reported lower catheter utilisation and lower CAUTI incidence in the protocol groups. The match to the PICO(T) question is close, since the intervention is a nurse-driven process and the outcomes include both CAUTI and device exposure. Pooling a large number of patients adds weight that a single ward project cannot supply. However, a meta-analysis inherits the weaknesses of the studies inside it, and the protocols in those studies may differ in criteria, staffing and surveillance definitions. A reader therefore needs the full text to judge heterogeneity and the designs of the included studies. The finding supports further consideration of structured nurse-led review. It does not establish the size of effect for any single hospital.
An Applied Project With Mixed Components
Pajerski et al. (2022) describe a clinical nurse specialist-led initiative built on a best practice guideline. CAUTI rates fell from 16.67 to zero per 1,000 catheter-days after a programme that combined education, competency work, simulation and audits. A fall to zero draws attention, and it deserves caution for the same reason. A before-and-after project has no concurrent control group, so secular trends, changes in surveillance and staff attention to the project may account for part of the drop. The programme also bundled several activities, which makes it impossible to isolate the contribution of daily review. The setting was rehabilitation, and its patient mix differs from a general medical-surgical ward. The source offers a practical picture of implementation. As evidence of effect, it sits lower than the pooled review.
Supporting Sources and Guideline Context
Karami et al. (2025) examined five intensive care units and found an inverse association between nurses’ CAUTI-prevention knowledge and practice scores and infection incidence. The cross-sectional design shows that the two measures move together, but it cannot show that better knowledge produced fewer infections. Chang et al. (2026) reported an association between nursing and nurse-led interventions and lower CAUTI incidence in a systematic review and meta-analysis, and rated the certainty of the CAUTI evidence as low. That rating is the most useful sentence in the whole set, because it tells a decision maker to expect uncertainty even when the direction of effect looks favourable. Patel et al. (2023) supply the professional guideline against which the other sources can be checked, and the CDC (2025) page reinforces appropriate use, safe insertion and maintenance, and timely removal. A guideline defines accepted practice, whereas the research sources test whether a specific nursing process changes outcomes. Weighing them together shows consistent direction across designs and limited certainty about magnitude.
The Practice Decision
The evidence supports a monitored pilot, not an immediate change of unit policy and not a decision to leave the process as it stands. A pilot respects the uncertainty that Chang et al. (2026) describe while acting on the agreement between the guideline and the pooled findings. Several conditions must be met before launch. The hospital’s governance body must approve the nurse-driven removal protocol, and the protocol must sit inside the nurses’ scope of practice. Infection-prevention staff need to confirm the surveillance definition so that CAUTI counts remain comparable before and after. Nurses need education on the removal criteria and on what to do when a patient cannot void after removal. Documentation fields must make the daily indication check visible, because a review that leaves no record cannot be audited. None of this academic exercise authorises a change in real practice, and any local protocol needs clinical leadership and patient-safety sign-off.
Monitoring should track CAUTI per 1,000 catheter-days as the primary outcome and catheter utilisation ratio as the process measure. Balancing measures guard against harm from the intervention itself. Urinary retention and catheter reinsertion rates would show whether early removal creates a new problem, and a rise in either should trigger review of the criteria. Run charts across the 12 weeks, read alongside catheter-day counts, would help the team separate real change from random variation on a small unit.
Conclusion
Avoidable catheter exposure on a medical-surgical ward, driven by inconsistent review of ongoing necessity, frames the problem, and the PICO(T) question asks whether a documented daily nurse-led review with protocol-based removal lowers CAUTI incidence per 1,000 catheter-days over 12 weeks. The pooled evidence from Su (2025) and the guideline direction from Patel et al. (2023) favour structured review. Pajerski et al. (2022) show the approach can work in practice, though its design and bundled components limit what can be claimed. Karami et al. (2025) add an association without causation, and Chang et al. (2026) rate the certainty of the CAUTI evidence as low. The most defensible implication is a locally approved, closely monitored pilot with clear outcome and balancing measures, and no promise of a fixed reduction.
References
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2025, June 27). Clinical safety: Preventing catheter-associated urinary tract infections (CAUTIs). https://www.cdc.gov/uti/hcp/clinical-safety/
Chang, X., Zhang, W., Fan, X., & Wu, Y. (2026). Effectiveness of nursing and nursing-led interventions in reducing urinary tract infections and catheter-associated urinary tract infections: A systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Nursing. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12912-026-05643-3
Karami, A., Majedi, M. A., Kamyari, N., & Vatandost, S. (2025). Correlation between nurses’ knowledge and practices in prevention of catheter-associated urinary tract infection (CAUTI) with UTI incidence in ICU. BMC Nursing, 24, Article 1252. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12912-025-03910-3
Pajerski, D. M., Harlan, M. D., Ren, D., & Tuite, P. K. (2022). A clinical nurse specialist-led initiative to reduce catheter-associated urinary tract infection rates using a best practice guideline. Clinical Nurse Specialist, 36(1), 20–28. https://doi.org/10.1097/NUR.0000000000000643
Patel, P. K., Advani, S. D., Kofman, A. D., Lo, E., Maragakis, L. L., Pegues, D. A., Pettis, A. M., Saint, S., Trautner, B., Yokoe, D. S., & Meddings, J. (2023). Strategies to prevent catheter-associated urinary tract infections in acute-care hospitals: 2022 update. Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology, 44(8), 1209–1231. https://doi.org/10.1017/ice.2023.137
Su, L. (2025). Effectiveness of nurse-driven protocols in reducing catheter-associated urinary tract infections: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Nursing Care Quality, 40(1), 39–45. https://doi.org/10.1097/NCQ.0000000000000811